Sunday, January 20, 2019

Spearie Winners 2018

Link to the nominees https://spearibfilmblog.blogspot.com/2019/01/spearie-nominations-2018.html
This was an excellent year for film, and a lot of these categories were quite tough to pick. By no means a comprehensive list, these are simply my choices for the best work and artistry in cinema of the year. I welcome any civil discourse and argument, as that is a huge part of what makes film so interesting, how different people have different tastes and feelings.

(All images courtesy of IMDB)

BEST STUNT CHOREOGRAPHY
Mission: Impossible - Fallout
Wade Eastwood, Allan Hewitt and Wolfgang Stegemann

Fun fact: this film's mere existence is one of the primary reasons I decided to create a category for best stunt choreography. That is, in addition to the realization that stunt coordinators and performers have one of the most important and precise jobs in the industry, and usually don't get enough credit for it. The stunt work in Mission: Impossible - Fallout is truly the best I've ever seen. The film captures almost every type of stunt: hand-to-hand combat, a controlled skydive, high speed vehicle chases on open streets, and of course the breakneck helicopter chase that serves as the climax of the film. More than just having all of these stunts, though, the film uses them to make the danger feel real. We know that the performers are actually performing the actions onscreen, and as such there is a legitimacy to the action that most films nowadays lack. They also avoid having the heroes feel too invincible. They make their mistakes, take their hits, and get by with a combination of luck and skill. Truly sublime work here, and it all went into creating what is likely the best pure-action experience of the year.

BEST VISUAL EFFECTS
Avengers: Infinity War
Dan Deleeuw, Russell Earl, Kelly Port, Dan Sudick and so, so many others

Marvel's track record with visual effects is a bit hit-or-miss. All of their films use visual effects very heavily, and most of the time the effects are solid. However, a few seem to take a step backwards in technology, or fall into a trap of overuse that is occasionally distracting. Avengers: Infinity War, the culmination of the entire MCU thus far, easily had the most effects to use, with multiple motion capture characters and myriad worlds to create, in addition to the traditional action effects. Thankfully, Infinity War hit it out of the park on all fronts. The worlds feel real and interactive with the characters. The action is exciting without reaching a level that feels cartoony. And most of all, the motion capture characters are a huge jump forward in the technology. Thanos may be the villain, but he carries most of the film on his shoulders, and the effects do not undercut the performance in any way. Every nuance, every tick, and overall every aspect of Josh Brolin's performance comes through. The film would not be the success it was without Thanos being at once threatening, understandable and believable, and the hundreds of special and visual effects workers deserve much of the credit for creating that. 

BEST SOUND EDITING
Mission: Impossible - Fallout
James H. Mather

Sound Editing details the work largely in the creation and timing of the sound effects themselves, mostly through post production. As one can see from that description, sound editing is dreadfully important to action films. In such an environment, this work can be the difference between feeling like a life-or-death situation is occurring, or watching a student film. Mission: Impossible - Fallout makes the most of its effects. From gunshots to punches to vehicles, every aspect of the world feels real and powerful. This makes the danger the characters are in feel all the more real, and thus the tension rises to its greatest heights. 

BEST SOUND MIXING
Roma
Craig Berkey, Craig Henighan, Skip Lievsay

Sound mixing primarily details the recording of sound on set, and the work in post production to add together said recorded sound with the added effects and music, including setting the volume levels on each separate track. Roma used all this work to create a world. At every turn of the film, the surroundings feel absolutely alive. At no point does it feel like any stock background or crowd effects were used. Instead, every single sound can be heard clearly and distinctly, giving the impression that, rather than a film set, this film captured the culture occurring naturally. 

BEST MAKEUP AND HAIRSTYLING
Suspiria
Mark Coulier

While horror is a genre that is often very reliant on makeup, Suspiria found ways to feel unique amongst it's genre. While there are plenty of blood and gore effects in the film, it also dabbles in creature design, body horror and even gender swapping. The numerous effects even allowed Tilda Swinton to play three different characters in the film, including the one seen above. Not only is the makeup work excellent all around, but it's creative, intriguing and terrifying. 

BEST COSTUME DESIGN
Black Panther
Ruth E. Carter

In a genre that often feels a bit same-y in the costume department, Black Panther instantly stands out as head of its class. It's creation of the country of Wakanda uses wardrobe to establish much of the world. The costumes here take influence from many different African cultures, creating a style that is at once a melting pot and wholly unique. The costumes are also colorful, varied and simply fun to look at. Even when the characters step out in to modern locations, their choice of wardrobe conveys the culture of Wakanda. Add in the mixture of classic and new techniques Ruth E. Carter used to make the costumes, including the use of 3D printing, and you have a vibrant example of how clothing can be used for world-building.

BEST PRODUCTION DESIGN
Black Panther
Hannah Beachler, Jay Hart and Alan Hook

One of Black Panther's greatest strengths was it's world-building. Wakanda was developed so thoroughly that it nearly felt like a character in and of itself. Much like the costumes, the environments of Wakanda found the proper mixture of tradition and technology to convey an advanced society that has not changed its ways in years. This feeling was integral to the story of Black Panther, which dealt with how to balance keeping tradition and moving forward with the times. Not only was Wakanda fully realized, but the film's foray into Korea and London also lead to some beautiful visuals, bringing out the style and culture in both places. Add in the unique look to the vehicles and weapons, and you have a fully realized world that is an example of a major studio allowing for full creativity.

BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
Roma
Alfonso Cuarón

Alfonso Cuarón has found a lot of success working with Emmanuel Lubezki in the past, so it was intriguing to find out that he had decided to shoot Roma himself. While a director serving as their own cinematographer can be a mistake, Cuarón used the opportunity to create a distinct and personal point of view. Far from his previous films, the camera in Roma is usually on the stationary side, using slow moves and pans to keep the subjects in frame. This creates a look that captures the important actions without calling too much attention to itself. It also employs a very large depth of field, often keeping the foreground and the background clear and in focus, so as to allow the entire world to be visible all at once. Though these techniques feel very subtle in the film, they are quite complicated, accomplishing the film's greatest strength: creating a beautiful and distinct environment without distracting from the film's lead characters. 

BEST FILM EDITING
Avengers: Infinity War
Jeffry Ford & Matthew Schmidt

Avengers: Infinity War stands as a decent contender for most ambitious film ever made. There were a full eighteen films that led up to this, and it took characters and ideas from nearly all of them. There are about thirty characters of significance, spread out into several different groups, and the film had to find a way to incorporate all of them while still feeling like a cohesive story. The fact that it managed to do so is a true achievement, and a huge part of why the film worked. Though it is over two and a half hours long, the film never drags. Though it has to juggle a half a dozen stories, it never feels overly rushed. Intelligently, the film relies on the viewer's knowledge of the characters from previous films, and uses Thanos as the main anchor point of the film. Because of this decision, and the expert cross cutting, the characters all feel like they exist in the same world, and are fighting the same fight, even if they are not in the same place (or even aware of each other's involvement/existance). It would have been very easy for this film to be a complete mess, but the achievement that kept it coherent should be acknowledged. 

BEST ORIGINAL SONG
Shallow-A Star is Born
Lady Gaga, Mark Ronson, Anthony Rossomando and Andrew Wyatt

Full disclosure: I have very mixed feelings on A Star is Born as a film. That said, the scene in which "Shallow" is performed is a fantastically well constructed scene, and one that serves great meaning for Lady Gaga's character Ally. While the song is very strong on it's own; it's lyrics and music are very emotional and have been rightly recognized; it is the way the song is used in the film that puts it over the edge. It is the high point of Ally's character arc, the moment she takes the plunge that begins the story of the film. While it's a little disappointing that the film peaks so early into it's runtime, that does nothing to take away from this rousing and heartfelt sequence, or the song that anchors it. 

BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
If Beale Street Could Talk
Nicholas Britell

There were many great scores this year, but Nicholas Britell furthered the argument that he is the next big thing when it comes to film composition. His score for Vice was very strong, but his work on If Beale Street Could Talk is pure musical artistry. Just hearing the strings and piano and flute cause me to well up with the emotion. Britell captured the story of Tish and Fonny in his melodies. The beauty of love, mixed with the sadness of their hardships, tempered with just a touch of hope. The use of classical instruments gives this an older feel, transporting us back in time to experience the era right along with the leads. After this film, Britell may be the one composer who can get me to see a film based solely on his involvement.

BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
The Death of Stalin
Armando Ianucci, Ian Martin and David Schneider 
Based on the comic book by Fabien Nury and Thierry Robin

Armando Ianucci has proven himself over and over to be a master at political dark comedy, and The Death of Stalin is perhaps his strongest work yet. Using the power struggle after Stalin's death as a backdrop, Ianucci and his co-writers manage to find the humor in the fumblings and backstabbings of some of the most dangerous psychopaths to ever come to power. It would be easy to allow the humor to detract from the evil that occurred in this regime, but somehow the laughs instead manage to enhance it, painting a picture of unchecked corruption that provides the strongest laugh-per-minute ratio of the year. Equal parts hysterical and horrifying, The Death of Stalin takes gallows humor to a brand new level. 

BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Joel and Ethan Coen

The Ballad of Buster Scruggs is an odd film categorize here. A western anthology, two of the stories depicted are based on previously published short stories. That said, four of the stories are original, hence my decision to include the film here. As one would expect, the Coen brothers accomplished a great feat with this film. The six stories bear no connection, yet somehow feel of the same world. Though they employ very different tones, ranging from tragic to macabre to downright cartoonish, all six stories touch on themes of life, death and nature in the old west. That even the weakest of the six stories contains some eminently quotable lines is as great a sign as any of this film's strengths in story and character.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Rachel Weisz-The Favourite
As Lady Sarah

In some ways, Rachel Weisz's Lady Sarah could be described as the villain of The Favourite. She possesses an icy demeanor, and serves largely as an antagonist to the primary point-of-view character Abigail. However, describing the character in such simple terms undercuts the brilliant depths Rachel Weisz imbues the character with. Though she first comes across as cunning and intelligent, as the film progresses we see more and more of the fear and pain lying underneath. Even deeper than that, we see her resolve and pragmatism. Though not exactly likable, Lady Sarah is deeply fascinating, and simply a blast to watch.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Simon Russell Beale-The Death of Stalin
As Lavrenti Beria

It takes something special to be seen as the villain amongst a group of men who shrug off assassination and genocide, but boy does Simon Russell Beale accomplish that. The leader of the NKVD under Stalin, Lavrenti Beria is constantly the smartest man in the room, and coincidentally the least morally inclined. From the getgo, the audience is rooting for this man to be brought down, and his blatant scheming mixes perfectly with Simon Russell Beale's dry wit to create the film's standout character. 

BEST LEAD ACTRESS
Olivia Colman-The Favourite
As Queen Anne

In this writer's opinion, Olivia Colman gave the best performance of the year of any kind. Her Queen Anne is a magnificent character. Broken both emotionally and physically, and possessing power that is far greater than even she can comprehend, Colman nails every aspect of this character. Through Colman's performance, we see the character come to change. Her journey and actions drive the film forward, and even amongst the incredible performances around her she stands above. Tragic and hilarious, often at the same time, every larger-than-life emotion is wrung for everything it is worth, without ever feeling over-the-top. This one will linger with you far after the credits start rolling.

BEST LEAD ACTOR
Christian Bale-Vice
As Dick Cheney

It's interesting, although perhaps unsurprising, to see the amount of film's this year that used humor to depict the dangers of unchecked power. Though Vice was an often-messy film, Bale absolutely owned the screen as Dick Cheney. Given the strength of his career thus far one would think it would be difficult to deliver a career best performance at this point, but he somehow managed to do it. At no point during the film does it feel like you're watching an actor playing a role. Instead, it feels like you are watching an intelligent man climb his way up to the greatest power in the country by hiding in the shadows. Though he comes across as truly despicable, the scariest part is that, through Bale's portrayal, you start to understand how he became the person he is. It's a sobering reminder that the most evil actions in history weren't performed by monsters, but rather by men, who found themselves in possession of great power. Though much of this film is played for laughs, Bale's final scene will chill you to the bone. 

BEST ENSEMBLE CAST
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Casting Director Ellen Chenowith
Tim Blake Nelson, Willie Watson, Clancy Brown, James Franco, Stephen Root, Ralph Ineson, Liam Neeson, Harry Melling, Tom Waits, Zoe Kazan, Bill Heck, Grainger Haines, Jefferson Mays, Tyne Daly, Brendan Gleeson, Jonjo O'Neill, Saul Rubinek and Chelcie Ross

Six ensembles for the price of one, the most fascinating thing about the acting in Buster Scruggs is just how deep the excellence runs. The Coen Brothers are at the top of their field in terms of the strength of their minor characters, and this film does nothing to change that. Characters such as Stephen Roots banker and Clancy Brown's Curly Joe may have only the briefest of screen time, but they make their characters endlessly memorable. Meanwhile, main characters such as the titular Buster Scruggs, played by Tim Blake Nelson, and Tom Waits prospector make just as strong a mark, turning even narration into something fascinating and character driven. My favorite performance may be that of Harry Melling as the "wingless thrush." Speaking not a word outside of his performances, he sells the character with his subtle expressions, drawing the audience's sympathy as his story turns darker and more desperate. In truth, though, there is not a weak performance in the bunch, and it makes for an exceptionally deep experience, and allows even the less interesting of its stories to remain fun and watchable.

BEST DIRECTING
Joel and Ethan Coen-The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

The western genre has been making something of a soft comeback in the last decade, and it is owed largely to three filmmakers: Quentin Tarantino and the Coen Brothers. Starting with the neo-western No Country for Old Men in 2007, the Coens went on to make True Grit three years later, a rare remake that improves upon the original. Now, they return to that genre with a compilation of six short films, all depicting the struggle between life and death on the frontier. That each of the six stories carries its own tone, while simultaneously feeling connected shows just how well these two understand the strengths and possibilities of the genre. Proving just as adept at wringing the sorrow out of an unnecessary tragedy as finding the humor in using a table as a murder weapon, these brothers use gorgeous visuals and excellent performances to craft a story that truly only they could have created.

BEST PICTURE
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

The Ballad of Buster Scruggs, along with Roma, are perhaps our greatest signs yet of how Netflix has changed the film industry. Their business model, free from the needs of the more straightforward studios, allows for greater experimentation within the medium. Now that they are releasing their films in limited theatrical runs, it seems as though they have found their niche. Buster Scruggs, an anthology film, may have struggled to find an audience under normal circumstances, but the fact that it can exist now is something very exciting. An example of the Coens at their unfettered best, this film alone is proof of the benefits of Netflix's model. Beautiful and sad, funny and violent, The Ballad of Buster Scruggs allows Joel and Ethan Coen to check off all boxes, and create a one of a kind film experience. I have already watched this film multiple times, and plan to watch it many more. More than that, I look forward to the future of film, and hope that a sustained level of creativity will be upheld for years to come.

Sunday, January 13, 2019

Spearie Nominations 2018

BEST PICTURE
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
BlacKKKlansman
The Death of Stalin
The Favourite
If Beale Street Could Talk

BEST DIRECTOR
Joel and Ethan Coen-The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Alfonso Cuaron-Roma
Armando Iannucci-The Death of Stalin
Yorgos Lanthimos-The Favourite
Spike Lee-BlacKKKlansman

BEST ENSEMBLE CAST
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
The Death of Stalin
The Favourite
If Beale Street Could Talk
Widows

BEST LEAD ACTOR
Christian Bale-Vice
Josh Brolin-Avengers: Infinity War
Steve Buscemi-The Death of Stalin
Ryan Gosling-First Man
John C. Reilly-The Sisters Brothers

BEST LEAD ACTRESS
Yalitza Aparicio-Roma
Toni Collette-Hereditary
Olivia Colman-The Favourite
Nicole Kidman-Destroyer
Emma Stone-The Favourite

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Simon Russell Beale-The Death of Stalin
Brian Tyree Henry-If Beale Street Could Talk
Jason Isaacs-The Death of Stalin
Michael B. Jordan-Black Panther
Jesse Plemons-Game Night

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Amy Adams-Vice
Cynthia Erivo-Bad Times at the El Royale
Regina King-If Beale Street Could Talk
Tilda Swinton-Suspiria
Rachel Weisz-The Favourite

BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Eighth Grade
The Favourite
Game Night
Vice

BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
BlacKKKlansman
The Death of Stalin
First Man
If Beale Street Could Talk
The Sisters Brothers

BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
Black Panther
Halloween
Hereditary
If Beale Street Could Talk
Spider-Man: Into the Spider Verse

BEST ORIGINAL SONG
Ashes-Deadpool 2
The Place Where Lost Things Go-Mary Poppins Returns
Shallow-A Star is Born
Suspirium-Suspiria
When a Cowboy Trades His Spurs for Wings-The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

BEST FILM EDITING
Avengers: Infinity War
BlacKKKlansman
First Man
Mission: Impossible - Fallout
Vice

BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
Hereditary
If Beale Street Could Talk
Roma
The Sisters Brothers
Widows

BEST PRODUCTION DESIGN
Bad Times at the El Royale
Black Panther
The Favourite
First Man
Hereditary

BEST COSTUME DESIGN
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Black Panther
The Favourite
If Beale Street Could Talk
Mary Poppins Returns

BEST MAKEUP AND HAIRSTYLING
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
The Favourite
The Sisters Brothers
Suspiria
Vice

BEST SOUND MIXING
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
First Man
Mission: Impossible - Fallout
A Quiet Place
Roma

BEST SOUND EDITING
Avengers: Infinity War
First Man
Mission: Impossible - Fallout
A Quiet Place
Roma

BEST VISUAL EFFECTS
Ant Man and the Wasp
Avengers: Infinity War
Christopher Robin
First Man
Mission: Impossible - Fallout

BEST STUNT CHOREOGRAPHY
Avengers: Infinity War
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Black Panther
First Man
Mission: Impossible - Fallout

Monday, September 17, 2018

Emmy Predictions

And now, my predictions for tonight's primetime Emmys. These awards are always a bit random, so keep that in mind going forward

BEST COMEDY SERIES
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
It's really tight between this and Atlanta, now that Veep is out of the race. I'm leaning towards the popular newbie to prevail, though wouldn't be surprised to see Donald Glover's popular series start dominating.

BEST COMEDY ACTRESS
Rachel Brosnahan-The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
There's always a chance Allison Janney will win whenever she's nominated, but I find it hard to believe even she can topple Brosnahan's excellent performance as the titular Mrs. Maisel, which has seemed destined to win this ever since the pilot premiered over a year ago.

BEST COMEDY ACTOR
Donald Glover-Atlanta
There's always a question of how important episode submissions are. If it does, then Bill Hader would dominate this category, as his episode submitted a huge range of emotion, landing heavy helpings of both comedy and drama, while Glover's episode doesn't even feature his protagonist, and has him playing a different character for the run time. That said, lately the submissions haven't seemed to matter as much, and so I'm thinking Glover will continue his excellent year with a victory here, potentially as a consolation prize for his series losing the big award.

BEST COMEDY SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Alex Borstein-The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Kate McKinnon will put up a good fight, but that was during a year where SNL was a much bigger player in pop culture than it was this year. Borstein is one of the more prominent nominees here amongst her own show, and with a subtle but memorable performance to boot. I bet she'll take the crown here. This category is very open though, and I could easily see Betty Gilpin or Zazie Beets sneaking in and taking it.

BEST COMEDY SUPPORTING ACTOR
Tony Shalhoub-The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
This category is even harder to call than supporting actress, with four of the men having realistic shots, 3 neck-in-neck. I'd guess that once was enough for rewarding Alec Baldwin's portrayal of Donald Trump on SNL, although I don't feel comfortable counting him out entirely. Realistically, though, I think this is between Brian Tyree Henry, Tony Shalhoub and Henry Winkler. Winkler seems like the best bet on paper, as he's a comedy legend who has never won and has the most fully comedic performance of the three, with Henry's being somewhat on the more stoic side. In the end, though, I think Emmy voters will welcome three time winner Shalhoub back with welcome arms.

BEST COMEDY DIRECTING
Atlanta-Teddy Perkins-Hiro Murai
Though Glover himself won last year for directing the show's pilot, Hiro Murai is actually the show's primary director, helming two-thirds of the episodes produced so far. This genre-bending episode is a great showcase for the skills and style he brings to the show, and should easily take this. You always have to watch out for pilots in this category, though, which could wind up benefitting showrunner Amy Sherman-Palladino's work on Mrs. Maisel. However, I suspect that this category will still favor the more overtly stylized Atlanta.

BEST COMEDY WRITING
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel-Pilot-Amy Sherman-Palladino
Here is where I suspect the pilot bias will play in. As I believe Mrs. Maisel will also win Best Comedy Series, there is no reason to suspect its opening hour won't win here first. However, if Donald Glover wins for the Atlanta episode Alligator Man, that is a solid warning that Atlanta will likely take the series award.

BEST DRAMA SERIES
The Handmaid's Tale
Though Handmaid's Tale wasn't quite the water-cooler powerhouse this year that it was last year none of the other nominated series seem to be putting up enough of a fight to take the incumbent down. Though two time winner Game of Thrones is back after not airing any episodes during last year's season, the return season was one of the most poorly received in the show's run, adding to the already difficult struggle of retaking a victory. The Crown is actually the best bet for a spoiler, having performed better than expected during the creative arts Emmy's. Though I doubt it has the power get more votes than The Handmaid's Tale, its popularity and quality should put its tally close to last year's winner.

BEST DRAMA ACTRESS
Elisabeth Moss-The Handmaid's Tale
This one seems pretty sewn up. Even if The Crown manages to top Handmaid for Best Series, Moss' showier role won't likely fall by the wayside. The only spoiler with a decent shot is likely Keri Russell, for the final season of The Americans. Final season's aren't a huge help in the Best Series category, but they tend to do wonders for actors, albeit not always enough to overcome a frontrunner with a heavy lead.

BEST DRAMA ACTOR
Sterling K. Brown-This is Us
This one is a little more exciting. While Brown was the clear favorite last year, costar Milo Ventimiglia was more talked about this year, as the second season of This is Us finally delved into his character's death. While I don't think Ventimiglia will outdo Brown's votes, he could take enough away from his costar to allow a third competitor, Matthew Rhys, to swoop in for a victory. Rhys submitted the series finale of his show The Americans, and as he's never won for his excellent work on the show, voters may realize that this is their last chance to undo their mistakes. Unfortunately for him, I believe Brown's consistently excellent work as one of the most likable characters on TV, along with Emmy Voter's occasional autopilot checking of last year's winners, will lead to him repeating his win.

BEST DRAMA SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Thandie Newton-Westworld
Honestly, I can see a world in which any of these seven women win this award. The Handmaid's Tale could easily repeat Ann Dowd's win from last year, or give one to Yvonne Strahovski, who is nominated for the first time here. I can also see Vanessa Kirby swooping in on a wave of The Crown support, added to goodwill from her role in Mission Impossible: Fallout. My, admittedly risky, guess is that Thandie Newton will take this category. Though her storyline was stronger last year, Newton continued to be the MVP of Westworld performers, and with three different actresses from Handmaid's Tale nominated here, lacking a clear frontrunner, I think Newton's emotionally powerful work could easily be recognized.

BEST DRAMA SUPPORTING ACTOR
Peter Dinklage-Game of Thrones
Again, almost any of these men winning wouldn't shock me. David Harbour will make a fight of it, but I suspect that Stranger Things simply isn't on voter's minds this year the way it was last year. Matt Smith could also make a play for "The Crown" (pun intended) but I suspect the nomination is his reward. This leaves the two Game of Thrones contenders. As great as it is to see Nikolaj Coster-Waldau finally get nominated for playing Jaime Lannister (which he really should have gotten for season 3, five years ago) Peter Dinklage's two previous wins show that he has a knack as a default win. Though he hasn't beaten heavy favorites, Dinklage's victories came during competitive years without a clear frontrunner, much like this one. It may not have been his best year, but I suspect that he will be the way voter's welcome Game of Thrones back in.

BEST DRAMA DIRECTING
The Handmaid's Tale-After-Kari Skogland
If Game of Thrones had only one nominated episode, or even if one was the clear favorite over the other, I would likely be betting on that here. However, its two episodes seem evenly matched, both representing one of the show's previous two wins in this category. Alan Taylor's Beyond the Wall is an exciting, action packed penultimate episode, much like Season six's Battle of the Bastards. Meanwhile, Jeremy Podeswa's The Dragon and the Wolf is an emotionally resonant finale fill or resolution, like Season five's Mother's Mercy. Their split is great news for The Handmaid's Tale's Kari Skogland, who would be competitive with either of these episodes on their own, but with them both taking votes from each other, should skate to the finish line. Had the Thrones episode The Spoils of War, directed by Matt Shakman, been nominated, that would be the likely winner. Alas, it was not, and Skogland's victory should come with a large margin.

BEST DRAMA WRITING
The Americans-START-Joel Fields and Joe Weisberg
The Handmaid's Tale's season premiere is a very solid competitor, and Phoebe Waller-Bridge's Pilot script for Killing Eve could win in many other years, I expect both will be going home empty handed. This is one of the categories where a series finale can be an incredibly sympathetic choice for voters, and wouldn't you know it The Americans' final episode is nominated here. Though I ultimately think both of its stars will not be able to ride the final season wave to victories, the writers will be the ones to take this home, where low viewership is less of a drawback.

BEST LIMITED SERIES
The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story
Probably the easiest category of the primetime awards to pick, American Crime Story should once again be a dominant force in the entire Limited Series/Movie section of the awards. Godless would be a solid spoiler any other year, but American Crime Story is too dominant to beat.

BEST LIMITED SERIES/TV MOVIE ACTRESS
Laura Dern-The Tale
Laura Dern's comeback is likely to continue here with a victory for her excellent work in HBO's The Tale. Her performance is subtle, yet emotional and powerful, all things that usually lead to victory. That said, Jessica Biel and Michelle Dockery will also get quite a few votes, and may be able to ride far greater amounts of screen time to win over Dern.

BEST LIMITED SERIES/TV MOVIE ACTOR
Darren Criss-The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story
Much as everybody loves Benedict Cumberbatch, Criss' path to victory here should be relatively uneventful.

BEST LIMITED SERIES/TV MOVIE SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Penelope Cruz-The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story
Here is the one category where ACS's dominance can be more of a hinderance than a help. Though either Judith Light or Penelope Cruz could win, they may wind up splitting, giving Merritt Wever the win. Ultimately, my guess, though, is that Cruz will wind up with the award.

BEST LIMITED SERIES/TV MOVIE SUPPORTING ACTOR
Jeff Daniels-Godless
Showy villain roles are great for awards, and that's just what Jeff Daniels has here. Though he won't win for lead actor in The Looming Tower, he's the best bet here. Edgar Ramirez is a potential spoiler, but I suspect the fact that two other actors are nominated for American Crime story will hold him back.

BEST LIMITED SERIES/TV MOVIE DIRECTING
Twin Peaks-David Lynch
It's never a great idea to bet against a film director who's nominated for an Emmy, as previous years show the Television Academy loves when filmmakers "slum it" (increasingly non-applicable term) on the small screen. However, Twin Peaks missed a limited series nomination, suggesting that it may wind up losing here. If so, Scott Frank or Ryan Murphy, for Godless and Assassination of Gianni Versace, would be happy to take it off Lynch's hands.

BEST LIMITED SERIES/TV MOVIE WRITING
Black Mirror-USS Callister-William Bridges and Charlie Booker
Though American Crime Story and Godless are solid competitor's across the board, Black Mirror is a very respected series of television films, which are regarded mostly for their writing. As very clever send ups of technology, I fully expect their entries to dominate this category in the years going forward.

BEST REALITY COMPETITION PROGRAM
Rupaul's Drag Race
The Amazing Race dominated this category for many years. However, with the times changing, the sheer amount of fun that Rupaul's Drag Race provides will likely place it above its more straight-laced competitors.

BEST VARIETY SERIES
Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
It's a shame that Samantha Bee won't be recognized for consistently showing The Daily Show that she should have been the one to take over for Jon Stewart, but John Oliver and Last Week Tonight have fully Usurped the position Stewart used to hold, as the smartest, funniest and most informative Variety Series on television.

BEST VARIETY SKETCH SERIES
Saturday Night Live
Though it wasn't as notable this year as last, it would be foolish to expect anything to top Saturday Night Live for this category, though former cast member Fred Armisen's Portlandia does try very hard.

BEST VARIETY SPECIAL DIRECTING
The Oscars
Though Dave Chapelle and the duo of Steve Martin and Martin Short had very strong specials, if the Oscars could win this category last year, what with the Best Picture snafu, there's little hope for anything to beat it for a year where things ran smoothly.

BEST VARIETY SPECIAL WRITING
Full Frontal: Great American Puerto Rico
Though standard stand-up-comedy shows can and do often win this category, which would lead to John Mulaney, Martin/Short or Oswalt winning, I suspect that the more political and important "Great American Puerto Rico" will use it's different format as an advantage to take this one home.

Friday, August 17, 2018

Who should take over for James Gunn?

One of the big talking points in Hollywood right now is the firing of James Gunn from Guardians of the Galaxy vol. 3 due to a series of offensive tweets from years ago that were recently unearthed. While I am working on an opinion piece about that situation, I do not want to publish it until I have made sure it is really thought out. There is some sensitive material involved in this topic and though I think it warrants discussion, I do not want to come into it half baked.


In the meantime, the confirmation that Gunn will not direct the third film of the series, although it may or may not use his script, leads to the question of who will take over for him. More than almost any other MCU director, James Gunn's own personality infused the first two Guardians films to a massive degree, leading to a distinct vision that will be difficult to replicate. Nonetheless, that is exactly what must happen now. It may not address the issues, but we can have a good bit of fun thinking about where this franchise could go.

This will be the sixth time the MCU has switched directors mid-series. Of the other five the only switch resulting in a weaker film was when Alan Taylor took on Thor: The Dark World, after Kenneth Branagh had directed the original. Though Shane Black's work on Iron Man 3 was roughly equal to Jon Favreau's on the original, the Russo Brothers improved both the Captain America and Avengers franchises, and Taika Waititi managed to turn the third installment of the struggling Thor series into a massive hit. Though Gunn's influence will be missed on Guardians 3, history has shown that Marvel is great at picking directors to take over their series, and may even be able to find someone who can add a special something to the property that we didn't know we wanted.

So, to start off with, I'm going to have some fun and look at a few picks that will never happen, but could be interesting in a parallel universe. Then, I will go to my top picks that are at least somewhat realistic. Without further ado, here we go...

Top 3 It'll Never Happens
#3
Nicolas Winding Refn

Now, of course, not only will this never happen, but it would be a terrible idea if it did. Nicolas Winding Refn has made a name for himself directing slow, artsy, occasionally pretentious and horrifically violent low budget thrillers. His strengths run almost complete opposite to what a Guardians of the Galaxy film needs. That being said, the very last thing a Guardians film by Refn would be is boring. The sheer level of trainwreck and poor matching of director to source materieal would render the film intriguing. Call it a morbid curiosity, but I kind of want to see what that would look like. 

#2
Edgar Wright

On paper, this seems like a perfect fit. Edgar Wright's career is full of creatively over-the-top action sequences, gut busting comedy and even a decent amount of heart. Take all of those, add a keen ear for proper use of licensed music (as shown in last year's Baby Driver), and you have yourself the perfect Guardians of the Galaxy film. Hell, Edgar Wright even has a history with Marvel, as he was the original director brought in to bring Ant Man to the screen. Unfortunately, that history is why he's listed as a "never gonna happen." Edgar Wright left Ant Man due to not wanting to work within the Marvel Cinematic Universe. He wanted the film to be completely stand alone, which goes against the world Marvel was and is creating. Especially after the success of Baby Driver, it's hard to imagine Wright's stance has changed, so chalk this one up to a distant dream.

#1
Joe and Anthony Russo

Since the success of 2014's Captain America: The Winter Soldier Joe and Anthony Russo have become Marvel's top dogs. They are also, thanks to their work on Infinity War the only directors other than James Gunn to have worked with the Guardians of the Galaxy. Their work with the team was exemplary, as they kept the Guardians irreverent tone, while simultaneously allowing them to feel like part of the same universe as the Avengers, with who they finally shared screen time. Though they've shown they can handle the characters, they've spent the last five years working on Marvel's largest properties. After the monumental scale and achievement of Infinity War and its upcoming sequel, it's hard to imagine these two jumping right back into another mega budget tentpole film. I could be wrong, but I think they've earned their rest. 

The Top 5 Hopefuls
#5
Adam McKay

After spending the early years of his career working on Will Farrell comedies like Anchorman and The Other Guys, Adam McKay has recently taken to writing and directing more realistic political satire. The Big Short was a film equal parts clever and informative, and this fall's Backseat looks to repeat that formula. As well, the level of satire in Anchorman's massive 2nd act battle shows both a strong understanding of action beats, and how to respect them and make fun of them at the same time. It's difficult to imagine his flavor being as interesting or unique as Gunn's, but he would likely manage the more comedic aspects of the film well. 

#4
Michelle Maclaren

Though Maclaren made her name on television, rather than film, her work on series Breaking Bad, The Deuce and Game of Thrones shows a cinematic eye that could suit a big budget franchise film very well. In truth, she's been looking to make her feature debut for a while now, even attaching herself to Wonder Woman, though she eventually left that project and Patty Jenkins took over. She's been working lately on developing the feature Cowboy Ninja Viking with Chris Pratt, so now that that's delayed and the connection is there, she's very potentially one of the names they are talking about. As she has had a strong hand in shaping the cinematic nature of television today, her work would not go amiss.

#3
Phil Lord & Chris Miller

This directing duo used to be known primarily for The Lego Movie and their 21 Jump Street reboot, showing a keen eye for momentum and fun that audiences latched onto. Lately, however, they're known as the guys that got fired from Solo: A Star Wars Story. While the full story is marred by conflicting accounts, it sounds like they were let go for ignoring the script and the Star Wars tone in favor of their own style. Thankfully, Marvel as of late is more open to director's expressing their own vision. It would be different than James Gunn's tone, but a Guardians film by these two could be one of the most fun blockbusters in years, and could allow Disney to apologize for firing them, in wake of Solo's commercial failure. 

#2
Taika Waititi

As far as in-house options go, this is their best bet. Taika Waititi's work on Thor: Ragnarok saved that series and character from being at the bottom of Marvel's popularity barrel. Ragnarok's largely improvised dialogue is an absolute comedic high point of the Marvel Franchise, and the crazy visuals and silly-but-still-cool action shows that Waititi took more than a few tips from Gunn's work on the previous Guardians films. Plus, it seems like Marvel and the entire cast fully enjoyed Waititi's personality, and you can bet that his touch would be welcomed back to Marvel with open arms. Without another Thor film on Marvel's upcoming schedule, this could be a great way to bring him back. That said, there's a good chance there WILL be another Thor film, in which case that would take priority for him. But come on, you can't tell me you don't want to see Rocket and Korg share screen time.

#1
Brad Bird

Ultimately, Marvel's best option is to find a new director who can put their own stamp onto the Guardians series while keeping it's greatest strengths. Best known for The Incredibles films, Ratatouille and The Iron Giant, Bird has spent most of his career working simultaneously in action, comedy and drama. Though many of the other directors on this list can handle the action and comedy required of the series, Bird is one of the few who could do all of that, and also possibly make audiences cry through his powerful use of emotion. All four of his animated features are immensely character driven pieces, something which would serve Marvel well. Though Tomorrowland is admittedly... problematic, Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol proved that he could handle a big budget, live action film, and he is largely responsible for elevating that series to where it is today. Perhaps not the most likely choice, a Guardians film by Bird would be an exciting, fun and emotional film, and maybe, just maybe, could have a chance to even improve upon the first two films in the series. 


Of course, these are all just my opinions. Everyone is more than welcome to disagree, as differing opinions is one of the most fun aspects of film discussion. If you have other ideas feel free to include them in the comments to start a discussion. Soon enough, hopefully we'll see who Marvel picks, and I believe they will make a choice in the end that will, if nothing else, create a fun film on the upper tier of modern day blockbusters. It won't be the same film Gunn would have made, but there's still plenty of potential. 

Tuesday, August 14, 2018

Eighth Grade Review

Comedian Bo Burnham made his feature directorial debut recently with Eighth Grade, the latest coming of age film. Also the latest example of the MPAA's flawed rating process. The idea that this film could be considered unsuitable for 13-year-olds simply because it doesn't restrain itself from showing the more mature language and ideas that 13-year-olds accurately talk about is ridiculous. If you are concerned at all about how appropriate this film is for a child just know that there is nothing gratuitous or over the top, just a dose of at-times heavy realism.


Starring Elsie Fisher, Josh Hamilton, Emily Robinson, Jake Ryan, Luke Prael, Catherine Oliviere
Written and Directed by Bo Burnham

Synopsis: During her last week of middle school a young girl struggles with her social anxiety.

Visuals and Audio: The coming-of-age film is not a genre known for distinct visual style. Though there are exceptions, they tend to be very low budget, and thus try to use a basic style of shooting in order to speed up the filming process. That is very much not the case with this film. Though it doesn't call attention to itself, the film often picks unusual shot choices that keep the film from getting stale. These decisions also change up somewhat as the film goes along, choosing to tailor its style to the individual scenes rather than have one blanket method of shooting. None of this is very noticeable without going in looking for it, but it does subconsciously add something.

Cast: One of the most intriguing things about this film is how hyper-focused it is on the lead character. While there are, of course, other people around her, her own difficulties relating to the kids around her mean that there is no solid friend group to fill in the traditional roles of a narrative. Instead, Elsie Fisher has to carry nearly the entire film herself, in terms of both comedy and drama. Thankfully she is more than up to the task. There is a certain level of realism and understanding to the character of Kayla. Though it may be on the lower end of the scale of character goals, Fisher's performance taps into how desperate the desire to be liked is for people of that age, making it feel like the most important thing in the world. She finds the perfect balance between wanting to change who she is to achieve that goal, and not being able to change. It creates for a brilliantly relatable and real feeling character, capturing the nitty gritty of adolescence. Ironically, it is because Fisher plays the dramatic beats of the role so well that the comedy works. She's not winking at the audience, she's playing it all straight, and the comedy comes because of the realism and relateability.

The supporting cast is not weak, per se, but they are very much there to support Fisher's role and arc. With only a few exceptions, many of these characters never get a chance to show multiple layers. This is because we're seeing everything from Kayla's eyes. We are not seeing any of these character as they are, but as Kayla sees them, where it makes sense that she may only see their most dramatic features. The most prominent exception is Josh Hamilton as her father. His struggles trying to connect to her are instantly recognizable and heartfelt. Though we never get to see his perspective, we can tell that he's somebody who doesn't really know how to be a parent, but is still putting his entire being into trying to succeed. Their relationship really forms the heart and soul of the film.

Writing: One of the primary things this film does differently than most of the type is the degree to which it shows the impact of social media on childhood. Preteens in this day and age live on Instagram and other similar websites, and the way they communicate is shown to be affected with unusual intensity. The disconnect between how somebody represents themselves on the virtual world, versus how they are in actuality is a prevalent theme throughout. Since these characters are still becoming who they will be, it is impossible for them not to be affected by this, and the film doesn't shy away from that. Supposedly, writer/director Bo Burnham actually took advice from his child actors on how to accurately portray this aspect, such as the kids using Instagram instead of Facebook.

Directing: In going from script to screen, Burnham expertly uses this realism to highlight both the comedy and the drama in the film. Notably, for the most part the comedy and drama are not separate. Kayla's awkwardness is often funny, while at the same time depicting a sadness in the difficulty she has fitting in. Some scenes do lean more heavily one way or the other, but the balancing act is mostly a positive. I say mostly because the way an audience connects to these moments can cause them to be difficult to watch. Just a warning, if you went through similar things to Kayla, then this film can often take you back to those moments, and become occasionally difficult to sit through. It shouldn't ruin the film, but can occasionally take you out of the proceedings mentally, though that is itself a testament to Burnham's achievement. There are also a few moments that highlight the less seen dark side of adolescence, which can be especially difficult for parents to watch. This is very intentional, though. Burnham crafts these moments to show that, though parents may try to protect their kids from the world, the world will find its way to them, for better and worse. This is an especially powerful lesson, as the scenes mark a strong change in tone, highlighting the intensity of the moments.

Verdict: Eighth Grade is a unique, hysterical and occasionally quite difficult portrait of youth in the digital age. Any parents might find it difficult to watch, but it is worth sitting through, as it will help show what their children are going through. For all others, it's worth seeing to find a Dramedy that doesn't follow any sort of cookie-cutter rule book, and makes its own path, although it will hit those with similar social awkwardness quite close to home.

Grade: 9.2

Sunday, August 12, 2018

Mission: Impossible - Fallout Review

The newest entry in the Mission: Impossible franchise is in theaters now. The series has never blown me away, but the buzz was good, so I decided to see if this one would change my mind on the series.


Starring Tom Cruise, Henry Cavill, Rebecca Ferguson, Simon Pegg, Ving Rhames, Sean Harris, Alec Baldwin, Michelle Monaghan, Vanessa Kirby, Angela Bassett
Written and Directed by Christopher McQuarrie

Synopsis: After losing a dangerous macguffin to a terrorist group, superspy Ethan Hunt save the world by taking a path that leads him back to a former enemy.

Visuals and Audio: Amongst the major spy franchises, Mission: Impossible has never been the most stylized. Bourne created a style of its own, and though 007 lacked consistency, its efforts to keep up with the times have often led to striking and distinct visuals. Aside from John Woo's efforts at #2, the Impossible franchise has been less visually dynamic, occasionally to its detriment. However, this film uses that to its advantage. Though not altogether distinct, the visual style goes 100% into making the action look as good as possible. Rather than using quick cuts and other tricks to hide stunts, said stunts are the bread and butter of this franchise, so the cinematography keeps the view of the action crisp, clear and easy to follow. There is something exciting about knowing that what you're seeing really happened, without much in the aid of CGI or tricky editing. The sound design is where this film really excels though. Every impact, every hit every moment carries a power, behind it. Sometimes called the "Oomph" factor, this mixture of clear visuals and crisp, intense sound is exactly what leads to the audience wincing during the hits, and leaning back when there is a large fall a character is facing, creating a level or immersiveness that is unusual nowadays.

Cast: Though certain characters have returned in this series, each installment tends to have a largely new supporting cast. For the first time, though, Fallout seems to be mostly focused on the same characters that Rogue Nation portrayed. Rebecca Ferguson and Sean Harris are back respectively as Ethan Hunt's sometimes accomplice Ilsa and his enemy Solomon Lane. Franchise regulars Ving Rhames and Simon Pegg fill out the rest of Hunt's team. The benefit to this is that the audience and actors are largely familiar with these characters, giving the film a sort of comfort and easy chemistry, wherein the main players don't need an excessive amount of introduction. However, this somewhat leads to the downside where few of the characters add anything new to their roles. The only one to really expand is Ferguson, who is the film's strongest actor for the second installment in a row. Though her Ilsa is familiar, she has new struggles that feel natural for the character, and her chemistry with Cruise is strong, but not without a certain level of uncertainty which aids the characters well. As for Cruise, there's very little to say. His passion for the series is undeniable at this point, and shows no signs of faltering anytime soon. His sheer physicality continues to be the main draw of the series, as watching the star clearly putting his life and body at risk for our entertainment will never truly lose its appeal. Dramatically, there isn't much ground broken for Ethan Hunt in this film. There are some attempts at giving Ethan personalized stakes, but the character has always been more comfortable jumping off of buildings than showing intimacy, leaving Ferguson the emotional heavy lifting.

The two significant new characters really add to the dynamic. Vanessa Kirby's White Widow is a new, sort of morally grey antagonist to the series. The character doesn't have a ton of depth, but Kirby is clearly having fun with the uniqueness of the role. More important is Henry Cavill's August Walker. A CIA agent assigned to watch over Ethan Hunt, Cavill proves to be the perfect foil for the protagonist. August Walker is described in the film as a hammer to Ethan Hunt's scalpel, and that description is perfectly applicable throughout the film. He carries a sense of brutality and simplicity that constantly gets in Hunt's way, and serves Cavill throughout the fight scenes. (I don't have to describe how oddly intimidating the moment he "reloads his arms" is, and how not intimidating it would be in anybody else's hands.) As such, he proves to be the film's most interesting adversary, even with the return of the previous film's big bad, Solomon Lane.

Writing: Oddly even for an action film, the Mission Impossible series usually shoots without a real script. There is an outline, and the director and Cruise have talked about the story arc, but the film is usually made up as filming goes on. This is to keep the focus on the things people come to these movies to see: stunts and action. As such, critiquing the writing is a little difficult since, in truth, it doesn't really matter that much. Is the storyline interesting? Not particularly. It's pretty basic and predictable spy-stuff. Is the dialogue strong and realistic? No, although there's less overt exposition than one would expect, which is nice. The one real strength in the writing here is how it avoids the greatest issues of previous films in its own series. Both Ghost Protocol and Rogue Nation spent their first halves building up to their second-act set pieces, with the third act being more of an "and-then" situation without as much anticipation. Fallout instead constantly builds up and readies itself for its final act, keeping that sense of anticipation throughout. As such, it's third act feels like less of a letdown than the previous two, and the audience exits on a higher note.

Directing: Interestingly, Christopher McQuarrie is the first director to return to this film franchise. Though Cruise had long wanted each film to have a different directorial style, he has had a great working relationship with McQuarrie over the last few years, continuing well here. Though McQuarrie puts the smallest personalized stamp of any of the franchise's directors, that actually does benefit the film somewhat. He really has a great understanding of what the audience wants, and how to deliver it to them. A bare minimum of focus is given to emotional and character development, while the rest is about building tension and excitement with fantastic set pieces in cool locations. This works since there is just enough character development for the audience to feel invested, largely resting on previous films, and a sense of simple motivations. It's not the most unique spy film, but it has a great pace that keeps the audience from realizing just how long it is, and he never lets the excitement die down for too long, using his quieter scenes to set up the next big loud one. There are a few cool flourishes he gives, but McQuarrie never lets himself get in the way of Cruise and the stunts, which, for this franchise, is just what is needed.

Verdict: If you aren't a fan of this franchise, Fallout won't do much to convert you. At the end of the day it is just another Mission: Impossible film. That being said, it's the best version of a Mission: Impossible film. Come expecting to see cool stunts and action, and not much more, and you won't be disappointed.

Grade: 8.6

Sunday, August 5, 2018

The Avengers Review

After four years of setting up their main characters, Marvel unveiled its magnum opus: The Avengers. Though not the first crossover film ever made, this film was the most ambitious, in how it kept the continuity of all of its origin films and managed to balance the different characters, prompting many other studios to start making their own cinematic universes. 


Starring Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans, Chris Hemsworth, Mark Ruffalo, Scarlett Johansson, Jeremy Renner, Tom Hiddleston, Samuel L. Jackson, Clark Gregg, Cobie Smulders, Stellan Skarsgaard
Written and Directed by Joss Whedon

Synopsis: When Earth comes under the threat of an alien invasion, S.H.I.E.L.D. decides to bring together the greatest heroes the planet has ever seen to prevent global domination.

Visuals and Audio: The first major thing of note is that The Avengers is the first film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe to have a theme that would be used again. Though character themes were developed for the other films, they remained in those other films, with new themes being developed for the sequel, save one or two moments. The theme Alan Silvestri composed for this film, however, has remained the main theme of The Avengers series all the way through Infinity War. As far as themes go it's pretty decent. It feels triumphant and heroic, which is very fitting for bringing six heroes together. It feels a bit like a missed opportunity, however, to not use the character's individual themes together at all, as it could have carried a thematic resonance. Likely the decision was made due to the characters mostly lacking memorable themes, but it's still a shame.

Visually, there's oddly not that much notable. The effects are good, though not groundbreaking, and the editing and cinematography do their job. The major aspects of The Avengers come in its acting and writing. The technical side of the film certainly doesn't hold it back, but it doesn't push itself forward in any significant way either.

Cast: The big question surrounding this film before its release was how Marvel would manage to balance six protagonists, four of whom had already led their own films. Thankfully, all of the actors are fully on board with the needs of the film. While a situation like this can to actors fighting and pushing to be the "main" character, the actors here all accept the film as an ensemble and allow themselves to work within the group. Chris Evans' Captain America and Robert Downey Jr.'s Iron Man do seem to have the most screen time, but they play off each other well, falling easily into their roles within the group without losing the characterizations they developed in their own films. Scarlett Johansson's role is heavily expanded from her introduction in Iron Man 2, and very much for the better. She is playing an actual character here, who is allowed to fully keep up with the rest of the team, and never shortchanged or used solely for titillation. Chris Hemsworth's Thor has less to do. This is likely due to the fact that his villain is the antagonist of this film, and if he were more prominent it would feel more like a Thor sequel than a true Avengers film. He doesn't have an arc of any sort, but Hemsworth manages to feel comfortable in his role, and he absolutely nails most of his comedic dialogue. Finally, the two new additions to the cast are Jeremy Renner as Hawkeye, and Mark Ruffalo, who takes over the role of Bruce Banner from Edward Norton. Renner doesn't make much of an impression, spending half the film as a mindless henchman before showing up in the finally to basically just fire some arrows at the enemies. Ruffalo's impact is far stronger. His Banner is much less intense than Norton's, albeit not completely lacking, which befits a character who was designed to fit into an ensemble. Ruffalo has fun with the role, finding a certain sense of humor in the character's predicament. Ruffalo also plays the Hulk through motion capture, and the character is given many of Ruffalo's facial features. For the first time the Hulk feels like the same person as Bruce Banner, which allows their situation to be more relatable. The Hulk himself is made far more fun to watch in this film. Though the character is still uncontrollable and unpredictable, this film uses those traits for comedy rather than for terror. This allows the character to be fun, as well as to not dominate the entire film.

The next step is finding a villain worthy of bringing together an entire team of superheroes. You can speak to the Justice League for confirmation that this is easier said than done. Rather than picking a new villain, The Avengers played it safer and took the best villain they had already introduced: Loki. Tom Hiddleston's performance as Thor's troubled younger brother was the highlight of that film, and he is similarly strong this time around. Now fully evil, Hiddleston makes the most of his scenery chewing, turning mischief into full blown malice and having a ball doing it. though his character is a far bigger threat this time around, he hasn't lost his sense of tragedy from Thor, and the trauma the character has felt is apparent through his actions, and through his more disheveled appearance. He manages to be a perfect foil for each of the Avengers, and gives the proper mix of threat and charisma to warrant an entire team of protagonists to bring him down.

Writing: Easily the largest challenge faced by the film was how to handle the screenplay. This movie had to balance six protagonists: four who had already been developed, one who had barely been introduced and a final one who had been recast with a personality change. On top of this, the film had to create a credible, yet interesting, threat that would feel large enough to warrant an "event" film. Finally, on top of all of that, it had to also be entertaining. To handle all of this, Marvel hired Joss Whedon, a television veteran who had specialized in funny and exciting ensemble television series. This proved to be the perfect choice for the film. Whedon gives most of the Avengers arcs of their own that complimented one another, and a strong and emotional villain arc that was more than just "big guy wants to take over the world." The way the characters interact, argue and finally work together feels genuine to how they had been established in their previous films, except for Hulk and Black Widow who are far improved from their introductions. Whedon also stacks the film beginning to end with his specific brand of witty, quippy dialogue. While this is a trait that would become somewhat overused in later films, here it serves to keep the film's tone light and bubbly. This way the movie never loses its sense of fun and whimsy, even when the stakes are highest. It also helps that most of these lines are very funny, and the actors posses capable timing to make them work at their highest. While the overall plot arc of the film is exceedingly simple, everything that had to go into making it work was so incredibly complicated that simple was about the only way it could have succeeded. While later films would add more wrinkles to the plot, anything more here would have weighed the film down. Those later films needed this one to establish the idea of these characters interacting and saving the world together, and the way The Avengers goes about that is absolutely what these characters and this world needed.

Directing: This was the first film in the Marvel Universe to be written and directed by the same person. This does come through on screen, as the film has many of the makings of a standard Joss Whedon production. This occasionally errs into a mistake, but manages to just avoid it. The thing that keeps it from falling down that hole is that the characters still feel and behave as they did in their prior films. Tonally, the Joss Whedon style is very light and fun. Though he has had heavier moments in his history of film and television making, he mostly avoids them here. The result is a film that moves quickly through its two hour plus run time, making sure every scene has some reason to keep the audience invested. There are occasional moments where this is lacking, but they are quick enough that the film never really loses the audience's interest. The sheer level of fun and enjoyment that Joss Whedon creates is admirable, and a huge reason as to why this film was and is a success. Even with as light as the film feels, Whedon still manages to give the final act some impact. He is able to tap into the differences between the characters so well, that the moment they all come together to fight off the threat, it feels like a momentous occasion. This final sequence becomes a standout action beat, and served as the Marvel third act template for several years.

Verdict: Possibly the most ambitious film of all time when it came out, The Avengers stands as a non stop thrill ride of fun. A nearly perfect balance of its ensemble and a hyper-focus on entertainment value and enjoyability take what could have been a messy film, and allows it to feel so coherent that some viewers felt it too simple. It's not a tremendously emotional film, but it is a tremendously entertaining film. It feels like a true event, one that served single-handedly as a proof of concept. It's such a success that many studios are still trying, mostly unsuccessfully, to copy it. However, it truly does feel like lightning in a bottle: the perfect mix of patience, talent and luck, that forced its series to be taken seriously in the popular zeitgeist.

Grade: 8.5